Ashton Kutcher made a series of ads for Popchips, but one of them in particular has now been pulled. The ad featured Kutcher in brown makeup portraying an Indian man named Raj. I'm not sure why the producers would think it was wrong to have Ashton in makeup and portray a black man but not think the same thing applied to portraying an Indian man.
Popchips, of which Ashton owns a portion of the company says the ads were meant to be funny and not a stereotype.
Billy Crystal has done Sammy. Is there much difference?
ReplyDeleteAnd Eddie Murphy has done white?
People have it in a bit for Asston.
Crap! I love Popchips, but now I know that a portion of the profits go to Asston, I'm not so sure I want them anymore. :\
ReplyDeleteYes people have done it before but it was a different time. Things of this nature are no longer considered funny or politically correct. When you add to that that nothing this douche nozzle does is funny or correct it's not that hard to understand why people would be upset.
ReplyDeleteI think this sort of thing can still be done, but in the context of SNL, for example, not in an ad for snacks. Stupid.
ReplyDeleteMan! Heres description of ashtons career right now:"fire in the hole!" lol
ReplyDeleteI can't speak for all of us, but I'm Native American and I personally find it offensive when people parody us. Casino & drunk Indian jokes aren't funny. White girls dressing up as slutty Pocahontas for Halloween isn't funny. I see it as no different than blackface.
ReplyDeleteIt's good they pulled this ad, but I find it odd that it was made in the first place.
This guy really is a douchenozzle.
ReplyDeleteI don't get the hate on this guy. I don't mind him. Can someone fill me in?
ReplyDeleteI don't get it either. He doesn't bother me at all.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhy arent't they upset abou the Metro cell phone commercials? Granted, the actors are Indian, but they are horrible steretypes portrayed.
ReplyDeleteHenriette - in what part of the country are you? We don't have Metro cell here.
ReplyDelete@Henriette i have seen those commercials and thought the same thing! This ad with Ashton is offensive also! I dont hate Ashton though but this ad isnt a good idea!
ReplyDeleteI wish they'd gotten offended in 2008 and pulled The Love Guru from existence. *shudder*
ReplyDeleteI feel oddly turned on. I better get to work and stop dicking around.
ReplyDeleteOn the flip side of Amber, I am American Indian and they don't bother me at all.
ReplyDeleteOf course my Tribe is only State reconized and not nationally reconized and litigation for our casinos has been ongoing for the last 7-10 years.
Not slamming you Amber, just offering a differnt POV.
Discoflux - I have been wondering the same thing! Why was that movie greenlighted?
ReplyDeletePeople just need to keep saying no to Ashton. How often do you think he has heard the word no?
ReplyDeleteJoElla - Didn't take it that way at all! :)
ReplyDelete@Lauren - I think it's a variety of reasons, from what I've read on here over the years. Some people are/were annoyed by his Tweets, which could be obnoxious (he defended Joe Paterno in one, for one example). Some people hate him because he cheated on Demi and think he is the reason for her demise. His comments on January Jones. And some people hate him because they think he's a douchebag and a terrible actor. I'm sure there are more examples, but those were the first ones that I could recall off the top of my head.
ReplyDeleteThis was a really stupid decision. I've never heard of Popchips...am I missing out?
To me it's not as offensive as Tanning Mom .
ReplyDeletehttp://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2012/05/nj_tanning_mom_appears_in_new.html
He's all chaotic and twirly all over the place. And he professed undying love for Demo, then cheated. His shows are idiotic- punked, anyone?- and he just keep doing more and more inane stuff.
ReplyDeleteI am not from India, but I thought those phone commercials were charming. I liked that the mother was the chattterbox, not teenager.
@Agent**It, I have a hard time believing that woman is for real. Who would do that to her face? Do you realize she's 40 or so? FORTY.
ReplyDeleteTanning beds = no, no, no.
Ashton, whatever. He does stupid stuff all the time, we shouldn't be surprised anymore.
ReplyDeleteEmEyeKay- I think she is "real". Perhaps she is trying to get her 15 minutes of fame (yuk).
ReplyDeleteThe base problem is they used Kutcher..I thought they wanted it to be funny.
ReplyDeleteHere's a great photo of that woman, if anyone hasn't seen her.
ReplyDeleteShe's 44 years old.
http://www.nydailynews.com/gossip/tanorexic-hollywood-gallery-1.27171
I wonder if she will let out hot air if someone pokes her, like the turkey in Christmas Vacation??
ReplyDeleteI can't help it, I like Ashton. And I really think a whole lot of stuff went on that we didnt' know (like Demi totally off the rails)
My Mom has this theory that the woman he was caught cheating with, was a decoy, she saw him and Mila on a show and said they couldn't keep their eyes off of each other.
Of course my Mom thinks Bravo is good tv and addicted to the real housewives shows..
Eddie Murphy dressed like a jewish old man white guy and acted like the stereo-typical jewish guy and no one said a word about it. I'm just not liberal and I don't get offended easily. In my opinion, I think every single race has a stereotype. No one is safe. There's also some truth in humor.
ReplyDeleteI don't hate the guy. I like his political/social views. But I do resent (and I'm sure it's why a lot of people hate him) his level of success. It's one thing that he has a career in HWood. But he's had SO much success, is making money hand over fist. I think many people (including me) feel that his level of success is nowhere commensurate with his level of talent.
ReplyDeleteHe was good at the Punk'd stuff. Maybe that's his schtick, being a producer (like P Diddly being a producer...yet has no talent for music himself). But getting acting job after acting job when you don't have much talent? Getting a primo role on a hot tv show (he's getting 700k per epi next year...highest-paid guy on the show)? Hooking up with pretty much any woman he wants? It just doesn't' make sense.
He should be more of a minor player in HWood (like his "70's Show" cast mates).
Lauren & it's just u, I don't get it either. I mean yeah, he's a doofus and has done dumb stuff (this commercial included, ugh), but there are other people in Hollywood who have done so much worse than him. I think he just speaks and acts before really thinking and it gets him in trouble. Granted, he's a grown ass man and should have worked that out by now.
ReplyDeleteWell, I AM liberal and I don't get offended by it. I'm part Native American and you can call me Indian all day long, I don't mind.
ReplyDeleteThe problem with stereotypes is that there is always some basis for them.
I'm VERY liberal and don't get offended easily either but I work in comedy most of the time so I know real funny from stupid and lazy. Besides it's not really about whether you personally get offended especially if you're not even in the group of people being stereotyped or made fun of but whether the group being stereotyped feels offended and insulted by their portrayal. It kind of requires thinking about the other person, seeing and respecting their point of view and not just your own. Not exactly in the Ayn Rand guidebook.
ReplyDeleteI have to say that I glimpsed the above photo on MSN (it was a small thumbnail) and thought, "What the heck is Mark Ruffalo doing now?!?!"
ReplyDeleteSorry, Mark. Love ya, Mark.
Note to producers: It's 2012. When you think funny is coloring someone's face, just go get someone who's face is already that color and see if it works.
ReplyDeleteThanks in advance!
Idiots!!! I should charge for this kind of advice........
_-_=_: Hey there! Haven't seen you in a while. Where ya been?
ReplyDeleteThe "cameo" Billy Crystal did as Sammy Davis Jr in the opening of this year's Oscars has been criticized as well.
ReplyDelete"...it's not really about whether you personally get offended..."
ReplyDeleteThank you! This shit is not okay. Period.
This type of parody is not funny. It's rude and embarrassing and I hate it.
ReplyDeleteOh dear... the white people are upset.
ReplyDelete@ Amber or JoElla: Would either of you mind explaining the difference between American Indian and Native American (sorry if this sounds ignorant, not intended to)?
ReplyDeleteAnd I can't help but think that Ashton kinda knew he might piss some people off with this ad and he was willing to take the publicity, Oops I mean chance....That's what makes him so douchy..
He should have had Jon Hamm do it.
ReplyDelete