Monday, November 09, 2009

Happy Anniversary - And Today's Blind Items - MV Revisited With New Clues

Today is the 3rd Anniversary of the site. That means three years ago I was sitting at work one day, bored out of my mind and decided to start a blog. Fast forward to today and there have been almost 9,000 posts and approximately 250,000 comments. That is a lot of writing from you and from me. A couple of weeks after I started the site I wrote a blind item which has simply been known as MV. What I thought I would do today and for the rest of the week is to give you a few clues to help you along the way to see if you can guess it.

Here is what the post looked like almost three years ago, and at the bottom is your clue for today.

***

Let me preface this post, by saying that if this story ever comes out, it would blow the music world up and shake it to its core..This would put the Milli Vanilli scandal and Ashlee Simpson SNL situation so far down the ladder it would be crazy..

Towards the end of last year I had a woman come into my office and she began to explain what she had done and had been doing for several years and it was one of the very few times that I just could not believe what I was hearing..I know the music industry inside and out, and I had never heard of something so extensive and pervasive as this..

This woman (S) came into my office because the payments she had been receiving had stopped and she wanted to either get the money that was owed to her, or expose what she had been doing to the light of day..

S is a sessions/studio/backup singer and is very good..Prior to her involvement in what I am going to describe, she made a very good living singing on commercials and being a backup singer for groups and other solo acts, etc..Like I said she is very good, but she does not really have that "look" which would make her a star, so record companies did not put her out front, but just used her talents..

In late 2000, a man came to her one day and said he needed someone to record some demos because he had written a lot of songs, but wanted a demo to shop the songs to singers and record labels..This is not unusual at all and she had done this type of work before and it paid pretty well so she agreed. What was unusual about her recording of the demos was how much work was put into the actual recordings..It was extensive..Generally there is not much time put into the recordings because you never really know if the song will even sell, and the money spent on recording could be put to better uses..These demos she was recording were actually being treated as if they were going to be released on a CD or to radio..They even did some mixing which was REALLY unusual..

After a few weeks she had recorded about over a dozen songs and she went on her way and was really oblivious to anything else pertaining to it, UNTIL several months later she was in her car and heard her voice coming from the radio, only it was another singer being given credit..(We will call this other singer MV for Milli Vanilli) She could not believe what she was hearing and did not know whether to be excited to hear herself on the radio, confused about the credit given to another singer or just pissed off for the same reasons..

What she did do, was to call the man who had originally come to her and had her record the songs..The man agreed to meet her and gave her a substantial sum of money and promised to keep giving her money every month as long as she kept her mouth shut. MV was taking off..(MV has/had several Top 40 songs and CD's. They could have gone to #1 or languished in the 30's..I really cannot go into much more detail or else it would be too easy to discover) MV was everywhere..on television, radio, awards shows, commercials..EVERYWHERE..meanwhile, S continued to get money every month and kept her little secret to herself..The guy who picked S was VERY lucky..Most singers would have caused a fuss, but S has always been in the background and was resigned to the fact she always would be, and was very happy just taking the $$, and did not want that to stop..

About 9 months go by and S is called by the guy because MV is going on tour and they want S to record some extra mixes and such for the tour..She agrees and does not really do much, but money is money..

Fast forward another year or so and S stops receiving money and after a few months of missed payments, calls the guy who explains that they need S to do another CD and then the payments can continue, but there is no more money unless she does more recordings..

S agrees and records another CD worth of songs which is released several months later and does even better than the first CD. This same process is repeated (I am not going to tell you the number of CD's because again you may be able to deduce and so I will just say the process repeated itself several times)

Well everything goes well for the most part for all these years and then no more payments, and no more calls and she cannot even locate our mystery man..S has not received a payment in six months when she came into my office and related this story..She did not even know the guy's name, but when she described him, I knew who he was and was even more floored than I had been previously..This was just something I had really not heard before..

I had heard of really altering voices in the recording studios and bringing in hired hands for one song or a large portion of a song, but never CD after CD and even doing extra work so a live performance would not sound staged..I told her I needed some time to check into her story and then we could proceed..It took two calls before I got the guy on the phone and he was pissed, scared, angry, threatening, remorseful..everything..It turns out the reason he had stopped making payments was he had been playing some shell games with the money between the record company, MV's earnings and MV's investments and just did not have any additional money..In addition, MV was not sure she wanted to continue on with what had been happening and so our mystery guy might be completely out of the picture..

I actually think the record company to this day has no idea what went on as the Guy was very good at what he does/did and knew how to make sure the record company was always happy..He stayed under budget, toured, made MV available, and made the record company money..

So a meeting was arranged in my office and S and MV finally met face to face..they had never done so, even though it was S who made MV a star..MV was rude to say the least when she saw what S looked like and it really upset me although S being her normal classy self could have cared less..

What we agreed to do that day was to provide S with one lump sum rather than a monthly income which was easier for Guy to pull off and S also agreed to never disclose her role in this drama and MV was on her own for future recordings and tours..

This involved literally millions of CD's and hundreds of concerts all over the world..The one thing I did get out of this beside my fee of course is a Gold Record autographed by S and by MV..I know it is the only one in the world..

***
MV has been or is currently married.

295 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 295 of 295
Hello it's me... said...

First, thanks ENTY.

Second, I highly doubt it's Avril for one reason:

Enty says that if this news ever came out it would shake the music industry to its core.

Avril is not that big a star. People have forgotten about her and she's worthless at this point.

Now, Jessica Simpson i still very much a star. So she could work.

And as some readers have pointed out, the timeline supports MV coming out in 2001 or later.

I doubt its Britney for 2 reasons: First, she debuted in 1999 and secondly, she always sounds bad.

However, Beyonce could work as her solo career really took off around 2001. It's possible her usual vocals were a bit covered while in a group however on her own she needed to pick it up a notch.

In addition, Jay Z would have had direct access to backup singers as he commonly utilized them on albums...

The only person being discussed who fits the timeline and would also shock the music world (while also hurting the credibility of S) would be Beyonce.

Beyonce being a fake would literally shock the world.

Hello it's me... said...

Really...It's MYA???

Who cares about MYA?

Are you serious?!

Yeah, cause I know Mya's songs like I know "Blame it on the Rain"...

If it's Mya then shame on Enty for thinking people care.

KESfromMA said...

I don't think its JLo. She was in the movie Selena in 1997 and did the singing for that.

KESfromMA said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Icecat said...

If I've never heard of Mya Harrison, how would this news rock the music industry. Sorry but I think this is a household name..
I also think the dates are fudged by at least 5-10 years.

My guess is:
Mariah (remember her signature high pitched shriek, I haven't heard her do that since her breakdown)
But then again I'm not into her so I could be just talking out of my ass!!

Any anniversary enty!
I'm a newbie (2-3 Months) but you are quickly becoming the first site I go to in the morning!!

Tracy said...

happy anniversary, enty! thanks for making this site a great place to visit every day!

what if MV was kylie minogue?

Norseman said...

Some solo debut record releases from around 1999-2001 from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_in_music and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_in_music. I started early in case the dates were fudged by Enty, and went up to 2001 because he says the recording happened in late 2000.

Anastacia (debut album 2000)
Pink (debut album 2000)
Mya (second album 2000, debut in 1997)
Mandy Moore (debut album Dec 1999)
JLo (debut album 1999)
Jessica Simpson (debut 1999, second alub 2001)
Alicia Keys (debut album 2001)
Victoria Beckham (debut solo album
2001)

Britney's debut and second albums were in 1999 and 2000. I don't know that I'd rule her out because of the MM Club. Just because she may have sung on the show, her child's voice could have changed quite a bit as she aged. However, I have no idea what she sounded like then, or in her early albums - maybe they are the same voice. (ditto for Christina, I guess, but I sense she can actually sing...).

Babs said...

I missed this one first time around, since I came in during the "Timmy/Shimmy" period. Lots of good guesses above, but I'm not ready to jump on any train just yet.

Thanks, Enty, for the daily entertainment! I love this site and all the commenters! It truly is my guilty pleasure during my workday!

Happy anniversary!

Alice D Millionaire said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Alice D Millionaire said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Alice D Millionaire said...

I don't think this is Mariah or Beyonce. I would love it if it were Beyonce though. Mariah has done too much collaboration for her to have faked the studio sessions. And Beyonce did that whole Fighting Temptations thing. I can see a "singer" who only goes and records her own cds and goes on tour pulling this off but if they did a bunch of collaborations and projects the logistics would just get way too complicated.

TheGoldenSockPuppet said...

Ever since the show Real Houswives of Atlanta showed how a COMPLETELY talentless chain smoking skank can get produced up into a decent sounding voice by a good not great producer, I think half the industry could be involved in this kind of embellishment.

Alice D Millionaire said...

TGSP I agree. Either that or they give mediocre singers like ScarJo the chance to record when there are millions of more talented singers out there. I sing as well as ScarJo and that really isn't saying much. I am not Pete Yorn’s biggest fan or anything but I find it hard to believe he couldn’t have found a better person to collaborate with.

Alice D Millionaire said...

I am not sure the phenomenon can be blamed on Real Housewives though. I think it really got going with Paris, Lohan, and then Hayden.

Cecilia00 said...

Mya is a great guess, but is she married??

Mod7 said...

Mya has never been married.

rachelstargirlrox said...

Okay. First off, there is absolutely no way it could be Britney. I've seen footage of her from when she was just a little girl (like 8 years old) and her voice sounds exactly the same as it does on her CDs. That and her voice is unique enough that you can tell it's her.

I like the Beyonce guess. :P I'd loooove for her to be a phony.

Cecilia00 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Cecilia00 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Cecilia00 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Cecilia00 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
info said...

I know this sounds impossible but I think the only person that would be shocking is Madonna and Enty keeps saying "Guy" so that's my 2 cents. The Britney's and Beyonce's of the world just wouldn't shake the music industry up.

Unknown said...

It's Mary J. Blige. She has a song "I'mt he only one" and hasn't sounded good live in years.

Karen said...

Do you think it could be pulled off when there is a movie involved? JLo in Selena, Madonna in Evita. That would take on a whole other element to the deception I would think.

Jackson Griffith said...

I still think Alicia Keys fits the particulars of the blind better than any other "artist."

Cecilia00 said...

I don't see it being Madonna. Hasn't her money always been solid? MV was having trouble paying...

Courtney said...

Karen, JLo didn't sing in Selena - they used real Selena tracks.

empyrios said...

IMHO it has to be someone pretty freakin' big and someone everyone collectively thinks is hugely talented if it "would blow the music world up and shake it to its core".

Also, as others have pointed out, the producer has to be someone known in the entertainment industry if he could be identified through description only.

I think if this were Mariah Carey and Tommy Motola it would be shock-worthy.

I dunno if it's shania Twain. She's been singing on CBC tv since she was 13 so.....

Alice D Millionaire said...

I don't think Mariah would trash Motola the way she does (for good reason it seems) if he had this kind of dirt on her. I realize that according to this blind he would be equally culpable but I think it would be really risky on her part.

empyrios said...

Enty's piqued my curiosity on this one

sassafrass said...

Ok, so if enty is the attorney mentioned in the post what is the earliest year it could have been? wasn't his age figured somehow in the past? 40 years old tops? He graduated law school 94-95?

I am trying to nail down a time frame.

austinrob said...

J-Lo did none of the singing in "Selena". If you knew Selena's music before she died, you would clearly recognize her voice. Obviously whoever said J-Lo sang in Selena is VERY mistaken.
I think she is the answer to this mystery. She had a "live" concert from Puerto Rico a few yrs back on NBC. She actually made an attempt to sing Selena's "I Could Fall In Love" and it was utterly horrendous!

alexxxa said...

let's not forget that Tommy Mottola was involved in Jessica's early career...just a thought

sassafrass said...

Another clue: at the time the blind was written, ent mentions MV has/had several top 40 songs. Does this mean 3 years ago MV had at least 1 top 40 song?

Icecat said...

@austinrob - It is not common knowlegde that JLo didn't sing in Selena. I love that movie and until today thought JLo did the singing...and I don't live under a rock either.. I usually know these random useless facts...

When Madonna came out didn't everyone realize that her singing wasn't all that great it was more about her style and dancing?? I don't think it is Madonna, but it would be VERY interesting if it was :)

I'm also thinking Mariah came out too early for it to be her....

URGH!!! This is so frustrating.

austinrob said...

@Icecat, it was definitely common knowledge to Selena's fans that we were listening to Selena's voice in the movie. You must have heard of her only after she passed away. I live in Texas, so maybe that's why I knew. Everyone here that I saw the movie with knew J-Lo was not singing. There was no way she was could have sang "Como La Flor" that way.
I still stand by my J-Lo guess.

austinrob said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Lolita Breckenridge said...

Happy Anniversary, Enty! Thanks for the work that you do - you make every one of my days brighter!

West End Girl said...

Congratulations on 3 years, Enty! Much obliged, as always; can't remember how I found here but am glad I did.

Re Jessica Simpson, I just youtubed her biggest hit, and this is it live :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mzzt1eNcSsA

and this is Angels live :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eOMMDJnv5Pk

They don't seem that different, if I'm honest and to be fair, most of her songs have her twang visible so I don't buy her for it.

That said, I'm still at a loss as to who it is :/

Icecat said...

@austinrob - I hope I didn't come across as snarky. I surely didn't mean to - and your right I had never heard of Selena until after her death...I did enjoy the movie. Now, I want to watch it again with this new knowledge. I guess what I meant is that most of the population outside of Texas probably thinks JLo sang in the movie ;)

And, yes, JLo is starting to look like a good guess. Did she ever do any commercials back in the day? Anyone?

austinrob said...

@Icecat, I didn't take it as snarkiness! I love the open debates on here. Yeah, give the movie another watch and appreciate Selena's true vocal talents. She was really on the verge of being really big.
But hey, thanks for those kind words...I appreciate em!
A little kindess goes a long way!!! So here's some your way!

austinrob said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
austinrob said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Definitely not Gwen Stefani. No Doubt released two albums that went nowhere before Tragic Kingdom blew up, and her voice has been the same since the first was released in '91.

Icecat said...

Thanks Rob!

I'm watching some old JLo on Youtube, and you've got me almost convinced this could be her. She sounds nothing like I would imagine her too. Way "auto-tuned"...
I have to admit I don't listen to too many music artists in that genre, so I've had to go and take a listen... but I love some good gossip...

lmnop123 said...

Happy Anniversary Enty!

My guess is Mary J. Blige if the timelines have been changed.

She's married and would fit the blind with the exception of having breast cancer.

If MV truly had breast cancer and is married how many of the people that we guessed fit that description?

ballyhoo. said...

Happy Anniversary Enty!!

My guess after discovering this site was taylor dayne, a little farther back in time, i know but she was huge in the 80's. she and anastacia have very similar voices and never ever had anything released at the same time so i thought anastacia was the one who sang for her. i'm sure i'm totally off but it is a really fun blind to guess at!

anyhoo, beyonce is a great guess, considering that "hoax" last year with beyonce supposedly singing badly.

JoElla said...

YAY for Enty!!

Okay my guess, the time line is not correct. That would be hitting way too close to home for the answer.

This needs to be a big, huge.. OMG GET OUT type of name.

Would we really be surprised if this was Jlo or Jessica? No, not really.

This really keeps standing out to me

" his involved literally millions of CD's and hundreds of concerts all over the world"

This must be someone Internationally known, and that will turn the music industry on its ear.

Only names I can think of with this much pull would be Babs (but did she really tour that much?) or Celine (tours and her Vegas stint) More current names, Bey. Why not her, rumor is she is much much older than she says she is.

Anonymous said...

Anastacia had breast cancer, and is married, but would it really rock the world if it were her? I couldn't name one of her songs if I tried.

For some reason, I thought it was the session singer who had cancer - not the star.

JoElla said...

Also gang, remember "commercials" are not just made in the USA. Many Stars run to Japan and Europe to do them.

CDAN Mod said...

i just don't think enty would love mary j blige like he does, if it were her.

jax said...

Britney fucking Spears OR Beyonce.

HAPPY ANNIVERSARY ENTY!!!!
so happy to know you, read your site and even the odd contribution.

you are a gem!

caralw said...

Not Gwen. Her voice is too distinctive. She also grew up with a band... not a solo artist until later.

Mya is a good guess. So is Shania. Hmm.

Susan said...

I'm not on the Brittany bandwagon simply because her voice sucks. It's nasal, monotone and always digitally enhanced. Would news of this variety regarding Brit really be shocking?

Beyonce, on the other hand, would floor people. Has she every sung a cappella?

Have any of you seen Beyonce perform? Is it obvious that she lip syncs?

I thought word on the street in J. Lo's day was that Ashanti did a lot of her singing. Again, I don't know if this would be shocking because J. Lo is not known for her VOICE. She's known for her bootie and low-cut Versace dresses and who she dates.

Beyonce, Mariah, MJB - These ladies allegedly have voices.

I don't think it's Mariah.

Definitely not Gwen.

I still think Beyonce.

Andrea said...

I actually might jump off the Jessica train and onto the JLo train. She is currently the only person to have a #1 album and #1 movie at the same time. To boot, the #1 album was her *second* album.

Even if people have always thought she couldn't sing, I feel like this revelation would shake things up.

Early J.Lo: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sK0DjYE-GVA&feature=channel

2007: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XMng0vCVog&NR=1

sara said...

Compare:
early Destiny's Child: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgiiRuEWoYY (can hear Bey's solo voice in this one)

late Destiny's Child: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dPR1d0gPKL8

Beyonce solo career:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mVEGfH4s5g

Just for the record, I don't hate Beyonce. For all we know MV was doing what she was told to do. I think Beyonce can sing herself, well enough to do live concerts, duets, etc., but her recordings have a LOT of backup voices and always have b/c of Destiny's Child. But listen to the "Bills Bills Bills" voice and see if you can hear it later.

uofazwildkitty said...

@mrr620, et al
Do y'all think the Canadian Art Prints copyrighted wild art is a subtle clue?

cdanluva said...

since we really can't trust the timeline beginning around the year 2000 - what about singers like:

Donna Summer
Patty Smyth
Diana Ross
Debbie Harry

Just some thoughts. . . .

Dolly said...

I am completely and utterly convinced it's JLo. I have never, EVER, heard her sing live. Every clip I can find is lip-synched, and even though the recordings are mediocre, the JLo brand was HUGE so this would be a shocker to the industry.

Has anybody ever heard/seen a performance of hers where she actually sang live? There's nothing on YouTube but a bunch of tracks that sound pre-recorded and remixed and even the duets with Skeletor sound phony.

Anonymous said...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2QGKDAP6yWA
proof jlo lip syncs

sassafrass said...

shush yo mouf about Debbie Harry!

sassafrass said...

alanis morrisette.

Susan said...

I definitely thought this was J. Lo back in the day when it came out. Her voice is probably more dubbable than Beyonce's, whose voice is very distinctive. Plus, Beyonce' singing voice is similar to her speaking voice.

And, seriously - I live for her new jam "Beautiful Nightmare." (Hangs head in shame.)

Unknown said...

Interesting note: In the second paragraph from the bottom, ENT says, "What we agreed to do that day was to provide S with one lump sum rather than a monthly income which wa easier for Guy to pull off..." It could be a typo but its Guy with a capital and not THE GUY as it would be said grammatically. I wonder if ENTY slipped and included the agent's name. GUY OSEARY is a famous talent manager, I believe he is Britney's agent in addition to numerous others. Look at his talent roster and we might be able to figurou out who this is.

Happy Anniversary ENTY. I've had a crush on you since your first post three years ago. Size doesn't matter to me ;-)

Unknown said...

Interesting note: In the second paragraph from the bottom, ENT says, "What we agreed to do that day was to provide S with one lump sum rather than a monthly income which wa easier for Guy to pull off..." It could be a typo but its Guy with a capital and not THE GUY as it would be said grammatically. I wonder if ENTY slipped and included the agent's name. GUY OSEARY is a famous talent manager, I believe he is Britney's agent in addition to numerous others. Look at his talent roster and we might be able to figurou out who this is.

Happy Anniversary ENTY. I've had a crush on you since your first post three years ago. Size doesn't matter to me ;-)

mlovesny said...

Hi. I disagree with all of the artists above. J.Lo have never toured. Mariah, Whitney, Kelly, Christina A. and Beyonce can all sing and they all have toured. It's not madonna. It is not Christina Milian- she is not a household name, nor has she done any commercials. Not mandy moore, could possibly be shania or what about Anastacia? She's not big in the us but she is everywhere else.
Congrats Enty! I love you and your site! CDAN is so much better than perez hilton!
Have a good day everyone.

Daveb said...

I wonder if the J Lo sex tape headlines might be the reason for resurrecting this old item? I also like the P Diddy angle because the blind says the Guy was/is good at what he does, always came in below budget, TOURED (my emphasis), made MV available etc. I wondered if the TOURED meant that the Guy was also know publicly as an entertainer?

hotchacha said...

It's not Nelly Furtado. I sat 3 feet away from her while she recorded and that girl could belt it when she wanted to.

MnGddess said...

Enty I LOVE YOOOUUU!!!!!

I have been hoping you give us some more hints. Lets figure this one out!

SugarMama said...

Has or is Mya married?

Unknown said...

The picture with the blind item is a big clue:
Diana Ross once played singer Billie Holiday in a movie called"Lady Sings the Blues" The picture is of a female singer with a flower in her hair like Billie Holiday. The movie "Dreamgirls" is based on the story of Diana Ross and the Supremes. Who played the lead singer/Diana Ross type character in the movie? BEYONCE!!!
Besides I can totally see Beyonce acting like a b**ch to someone who was not as put together as herself

ex1414 said...

I'll confess that I didn't read all 271 comments before posting, but I did try to skim in case this one has been effectively debunked: I've always thought this was Macy Grey.

Unknown said...

the pics he used in this post say "Canada"...a clue? i am so lost! i can be swayed to believe it is anyone mentioned!

MATA v2.0 said...

I looked at Mya's Wikipedia page and it does kind of sound right on, but why would she shake up the music business to it's core? I don't get it. Was she highly respected as a real singer?

Mario said...

HAPPY ANNIVERSARY ENT!You really deserve it.
Please NUNAURBIZ, don't ever mention Tina Turner in this blog again!
I think it's a sexy singer like JLO or (don't laugh) Jessica Simpson!

tinkerfairy said...

I'm wondering why, after all that time of singing and accepting money, S never asked for the guy's name???

ballyhoo. said...

hey guys, i don't think i was clear in my first post - i think taylor dayne was the star and anastacia was the one recording for taylor. :D

Miss MacLean said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Miss MacLean said...

Michelle Branch.

Shes married (I'm not sure if she still is) and has at least one child.

According to Wikipedia (which isn't the best source, but w/e) Her first album "The Spirit Room" was released in August of 2001. In 2003 she was nominated for a Grammy for Best New Artist, but was edged out by Norah Jones. Her second album "Hotel Paper" was released in 2003. The single "Are you happy now?" was nominated for a Grammy (in the Best Female Rock Vocal Performance category) and was edged out this time by Pink (for Trouble).

I found it interesting that 2 artists Enty ruled out, won over her.

I'm looking for more, but so far its my best guess.

crila16 said...

I actually know for a fact it's not Mariah. I knew a woman who she auditioned for (in person) back in the 80's. The woman refused to take her on as a client, because even tho her voice was amazing, she didn't have the look of a star. Mariah ended up going to another agent and hit it big 2 years later. The same woman told me she also had rejected Julia Roberts, because she felt she looked like a horse. She told me she was kicking herself.

crila16 said...

JLo has a horrible voice. It's incredibly weak. I'm assuming that(S) must have an amazing voice/gift if a producer is willing to search her out and pay her off for this long to dub a more attractive person. Now Christine A. has an amazing voice. Absolutely amazing. That voice would be worth it.

crila16 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
crila16 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
budford said...

WH, with her aging producer. early songs were dancey and did not require the vocals of the soundtrack songs. Had to be able to perform on the soundtrack songs. She was a back up singer like her relatives, but she had the right look. They can sing, but arent huge stars. Maybe that was the extent of her actual ability to sing.

Any doubt she would be unpleasant to meet under those circumstances? No way would anyone sneak this past Madonna, but her?

His background shows all kinds of interesting activity. Fired alot for cause including financial misdeeds. Old school background, put in a pretty face with someone else singing. Most of his most profitable artists are bad singers.

One of the tours included world tour in the name. Is "hundreds of shows" really all that many in the scheme of things? The imptetus to come back after the break would be the acting, but had to be able to sing on the album.

Nothing here says she could not sing, but maybe she just could not sing certain things. It certainly seems like now, however, she cant sing and they have a perfect excuse.

budford said...

WH, with her aging producer. early songs were dancey and did not require the vocals of the soundtrack songs. Had to be able to perform on the soundtrack songs. She was a back up singer like her relatives, but she had the right look. They can sing, but arent huge stars. Maybe that was the extent of her actual ability to sing.

Any doubt she would be unpleasant to meet under those circumstances? No way would anyone sneak this past Madonna, but her?

His background shows all kinds of interesting activity. Fired alot for cause including financial misdeeds. Old school background, put in a pretty face with someone else singing. Most of his most profitable artists are bad singers.

One of the tours included world tour in the name. Is "hundreds of shows" really all that many in the scheme of things? The imptetus to come back after the break would be the acting, but had to be able to sing on the album.

Nothing here says she could not sing, but maybe she just could not sing certain things. It certainly seems like now, however, she cant sing and they have a perfect excuse.

crila16 said...

Found one of JLo on You Tube singing live. You could tell it was definitely her, because not only was it horrible (as I think her voice is) she kept talking as she was singing. It was definitely her. I think Jessica's voice is just OK...and I don't know if she's a big enough deal. She's a US tour, not international. She also contorts her face strangely when she's singing, because she's pushing herself to get the notes out. She also had already a duet out in 1998 or 1999 with Nick Lachey. Britney would be a better guess, but I definitely don't think it's her at all.

crila16 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
crila16 said...

I now am thinking it's Mya or Ashanti. Ashanti is a HUGE success in the R&B world and broke records. I think she just had her baby too. She's married to Nelly.

crila16 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Also, Enty said he "fudged" the dates. I could easily imagine him going 10 - 20 years back to make this more difficult.

WAIT!
Here's a crazy crazy CRAZY thought. Michael Jackson, starting with his solo album! IMHO, That's about the ONLY person that would "blow the music world up and shake it to its core." Plus, as he's deceased, less trouble for Enty (I don't mean that callously, just legally)

Yes, I am ignoring that Enty refers to MV as she. Why not fudge on the sex? Maybe when his voice changed it didn't sound as good. Also - I've heard Michael's voice in person was never as high-pitched as his singing voice, and would surprise those who met him.

And the interview that MV was going to have? Maybe it was the Martin Bashir interview.

Of course, maybe it's TOO crazy....

ericaomega said...

Not Lauryn Hill. She may have disappeared, but she is definitely talented and does not lip sing at concerts (has a Svengali, manic genius quality that allows her to shift through notes effortlessly).

lilo723 said...

Ok, I know this post is pretty old, but I just wanted to comment on Shania. She would totally be hateful to someone she is meeting that recorded for her. When she sang in Memphis back in like 2003, she had students from my high school sing with her. They were so disappointed. They said they were not allowed to look her in the eye or speak with her. She never talked with them and one did actually look at her, she yelled at one of her handlers and had them tell the student not to speak anymore. She had another girl sing her very first single with her, what made you say that. That girls said she did all the vocals live and for herself, but they nevern practiced together live, just sang together the time they wereiactually on stage. shania did not stand very close to this girl while they sang. Having said all that I don't believe MV is Shawhina, which is what we called her after the show was over. I think it is Mariah, Whitney, Madonna, someone higher profile.

lilo723 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Dolly72 said...

Based on all the clues, I have 3 top runners:)
Toni Braxton (who, funny enough, was thought to have breast cancer in 2007- just like S in the clues)
J Lo
Britney spears

All 3 meet the clues below, that were posted by Enty


2009- Been seperated or divorced at least once
Born in the US
2010- Singer or spouse has a nickname or a hyphen in their name
2011- Released a CD in the last year
2009- Has at least one child
2009- Has been or is currently married
Actual singer almost died in spring 2007 from breast cancer

Unknown said...

It's not Jennifer Lopez for the simple reason that she has never sounded all that good even on her recordings. Her voice is thin and people have commented on it. If S is as good as they say, and if JLo were MV, her voice would sound great on recordings and it simply doesn't.

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 295 of 295   Newer› Newest»

Advertisements

Popular Posts from the last 30 days